Professional Practice Architecture Practice Test

In the event of flooding caused by a roof repair, who is primarily liable for the damages?

1. Architect "A", he should have checked the work of the roofing contractor

2. The roofing contractor, as he performed the repair

3. The couple, since they hired their father

4. Not applicable

The correct answer is: The roofing contractor, as he performed the repair

The roofing contractor holds primary liability for the damages resulting from flooding caused by the roof repair. This is because the contractor is responsible for the quality and execution of their work. When a contractor is hired to perform a specific task, such as repairing a roof, they are expected to complete that task in accordance with industry standards and best practices. If the flooding occurred due to issues arising from the repair, such as improper installation or failure to follow proper procedures, it is reasonable to attribute liability to the roofing contractor. Their expertise and direct involvement in the repair process make them accountable for ensuring that their work does not lead to further problems, such as water infiltration or damage. In contrast, while the architect may have a role in overseeing the overall project and ensuring that plans and specifications are adhered to, they are typically not responsible for directly supervising every detail of the construction or repair process performed by contractors. Similarly, the hiring of a family member does not inherently transfer liability for professional work performed to the client in this context. Thus, the roofing contractor's responsibilities are paramount in this scenario.